Skip to content
RoofElm

Yard

Driveway repair or replacement, measured first

How concrete and asphalt driveways are built, when sealing or patching is enough, how to size a pour, and what a bid has to say.

By RoofElm Editorial Team Updated 8 min read

Concrete slab, residential
4 in; 5 in heavy loads
Cars on new concrete
Wait at least 7 days
Heavy loads on concrete
Wait at least 28 days
Asphalt, first sealcoat
About 2 to 5 years
Illustration: a driveway cross-section showing compacted base, concrete slab, control joints and a slope away from the garage
A driveway in section: base, slab, joints and slope.

In short

A driveway is a surface sitting on a base, so most failures start below the surface. A concrete slab of at least 4 inches on a compacted base, with joints to control cracking and proper curing, is the standard one industry guide gives. Asphalt needs sealing as it ages, not at once. Cracks and a sunken edge point to a base or drainage problem, and that matters more than the top coat. Size any pour in cubic yards first: a 12 by 40 foot driveway at 4 inches is about 5.9 cubic yards before waste. Permits, frost depth and the rules for the apron at the street vary by locality.

Repair, resurface or replace

Look at why the driveway failed before you pick a fix. Hairline cracks and a dull, dry surface are surface problems. Settled or heaved sections, wide cracks, standing water and a crumbling edge mean the base, the drainage or the tree roots underneath are moving, and a patch on top will fail again.

  • Seal or patch: small cracks, a worn surface, a few chipped joints.
  • Section replacement: one slab that has settled or broken while the rest is sound.
  • Full replacement: a failed base, widespread cracking or a driveway that holds water.

Where water goes matters. A driveway that slopes toward the house, or a downspout that empties onto it, will undermine the base. Read gutters and drainage before you pay to pour anything.

Concrete: thickness, base and joints

The numbers here come from guidance for residential flatwork published by the Indiana Ready Mixed Concrete Association. Other regions publish their own, so treat these as a checklist to compare against your bids, not as a code. It says the minimum recommended thickness for residential flatwork is 4 inches, and 5 inches where delivery vehicles or other heavy loads are expected. It calls for removing unstable material to a depth of at least 6 inches, replacing it with crushed stone or gravel compacted to 95 percent density, and a compacted sub-base at least 4 inches thick.

Joints control where the slab cracks. The Portland Cement Association says joints, typically sawn, are made to control cracking, and that a correctly designed joint puts the crack below the joint. The Indiana guide gives a spacing rule: 2 to 2.5 times the slab thickness in inches, read as feet. For a 4-inch slab that is 8 to 10 feet, with panels as square as possible and joints cut as soon as possible to a depth of at least a quarter of the thickness. It also lists a 6 by 9 foot panel for 4 inches, so ask your contractor to show the joint layout on a sketch.

That guide also sets a mix: slump at placement not over 4 inches, plus or minus 1, a water to cement ratio of 0.45 or less, 6 percent air content plus or minus 1.5 percent, and a compressive strength of 4,500 psi at 28 days. Air content and strength specs depend on your climate and your supplier, so ask the contractor which mix is specified and why.

Sizing a pour, worked out

Concrete is sold by the cubic yard, which is 27 cubic feet. The formula: length times width times thickness in feet, divided by 27, then add waste for uneven ground and spills.

Example: a 12 by 40 foot driveway with 10% waste
ThicknessVolumeWith 10% waste
4 inches160 cu ft, 5.93 cu yd6.52 cu yd
5 inches200 cu ft, 7.41 cu yd8.15 cu yd

That is 480 square feet times one third of a foot for 4 inches. A job this size is a ready-mix truck, not bags. You can run your own numbers, and the same math for gravel base, in the yard and concrete calculator. Compare the cubic yards in each bid to your own figure: a bid well above it might include thickness you did not ask for, and one well below it might be thin.

Curing, cold weather and salt

New concrete is not finished when it looks hard. The Indiana guide says wet curing should start right after the final finish and run at least 1 and up to 7 days, with a curing compound afterward if wet curing is under 3 days. It says concrete can take foot traffic after 48 hours, vehicles after at least 7 days and heavy loads such as dumpsters or RVs only after 28 days. It also says never to place concrete on frozen sub-base, to avoid deicing salts and use sand for at least the first winter, and to avoid deicers containing magnesium chloride, calcium chloride or ammonium compounds.

Asphalt: sealing and repair

The Asphalt Institute says a seal coat renews an asphalt surface that has become dry and brittle, closes small surface cracks and helps prevent loss of surface stone. It says a well-designed low-traffic pavement should not need sealing for roughly 2 to 5 years after paving, depending on climate and the quality of the original work, and that after that you seal when you see signs of aging. It does not present sealing as a fix for structural failure, and it does not recommend sealers that contain coal tar. Ask any sealer exactly which product they use.

The Asphalt Institute points to its own driveway design publications for thickness. We do not quote an asphalt thickness here, so ask each paver for the compacted asphalt thickness and the base depth in writing, and ask which standard they follow.

Permits, frost depth and what to ask

Rules for the apron where your driveway meets the street, the curb cut, drainage to the street, width limits and the share of the lot you can pave come from your city or county. The Indiana guide itself says the apron and the public right of way may fall under local rules. Frost depth varies by region and by county and can change how a base is built, so ask the building office what applies to your lot. Call your building office, then see permits and inspections. Neighborhood associations can add their own rules.

  1. Ask for the thickness, the base material and its compacted depth, the joint plan and the curing method in the written bid.
  2. Ask who pulls the permit and who handles the apron work in the street right of way.
  3. Ask where the old slabs go and whether removal and disposal are in the price.
  4. Get a certificate of insurance sent by the insurer. The contractor hiring guide explains why.
  5. Ask for the workmanship warranty in writing and the date you can drive on the new surface.
  6. Compare each bid line by line using the estimate reading guide.

Size and thickness

Square feet, thickness and the base under it drive material and labor.

Removal and access

Breaking out old slabs, hauling and equipment access add to the job.

Finish and drainage

Broom finish versus decorative surfaces, and any added drains or grading, change the scope.

DIY is sensible for sealing cracks and patching small areas on a sound base. A full pour is a crew job: the timing and the finishing do not allow a second try.

Common questions

How thick should a concrete driveway be?

The Indiana Ready Mixed Concrete Association guide gives 4 inches as the minimum for residential flatwork and 5 inches where delivery vehicles or heavy loads are expected. Confirm the local rule with your building office.

How long before I can drive on new concrete?

That guide says at least 7 days for vehicles, with heavy loads waiting at least 28 days. Your contractor may give a different date for your mix and weather, so get it in writing.

When should I seal an asphalt driveway?

The Asphalt Institute says a well-built low-traffic driveway may not need it for roughly 2 to 5 years, then seal as signs of aging appear. It does not recommend coal-tar sealers.

Do I need a permit to replace a driveway?

It depends on your city or county. The apron and curb cut at the street are the parts most likely to fall under local rules, so ask your building office before work starts.

Sources

Facts checked on November 19, 2026 against the pages above. The concrete figures come from one state association's guide; mixes, frost depth, permits and street-apron rules vary by locality, so confirm with your building office and contractor.