Bids
Reading a contractor estimate before you sign it
Scope, materials, unit prices, exclusions and payment terms: what each line should say and what a gap costs you.
By RoofElm Editorial Team Updated 6 min read
- Compare bids on
- The same written scope
- Name in every bid
- Brand, product, quantity
- Watch for
- Allowances and exclusions
- Rules differ by
- State
In short
An estimate is a price for a described job, and a bid can only be compared with another bid if both describe the same job. Look for the scope of work, named materials, quantities, how surprises are priced, what is left out, who pulls the permit and when you pay. A vague line is not a bargain: it is a change order waiting to happen. Some states require written contracts above a set amount or with specific wording, so check the state help pages and your attorney general's consumer office.
Estimate, bid, quote and contract
People use these words loosely, and so do contractors. An estimate is an educated guess that may change. A bid or quote is a price for a stated scope, and it should say how long it is good for. A contract is the signed agreement that makes the price and scope binding on both sides. Ask which one you are holding. If a document says "estimate" and also says the final price may be higher, you are not holding a price.
Many states require a written contract for home improvement work, some only above a dollar amount, and some require specific wording or notices. Those rules are state law and the details differ. Ask your attorney general's consumer office what applies, and read contracts, warranties and lien waivers before signing.
The scope of work: what is actually being done
The scope is the heart of a bid. It should describe the work in steps, not in a slogan. "Roof replacement" is a slogan. "Remove existing shingles and underlayment to the deck, replace damaged decking, install underlayment, flashing and shingles, install vents, haul away debris" is a scope. If your bid reads like the slogan, ask for the steps, and ask what is not included.
- Area and quantity: square feet, linear feet, number of windows or squares of roof, with the measurements the contractor used.
- Materials by name: brand, product line, color, size and grade, not "standard shingles" or "quality siding".
- Prep and removal: what gets torn out, what gets protected, and where the debris goes.
- Cleanup: who hauls the waste, and whether the yard gets a nail sweep.
- Schedule: a start window, a finish window, and what happens when weather or materials delay the job.
For a roof, the roof replacement page explains squares and bundles, and the roof squares calculator lets you check the quantity in each bid against your own measurement.
Allowances, unit prices and surprises
Some jobs hide unknowns: rotted wood behind siding, a second layer of roofing, wiring that does not meet code once a wall is open. A good bid says how those will be priced before they appear. Look for three things.
Allowance
A set amount for something not yet chosen, such as fixtures or tile. If you pick something that costs more than the allowance, you pay the difference. Ask what the allowance covers and who picks the item.
Unit price
A stated price per sheet of decking, per linear foot of trim or per square, used if hidden damage is found. It keeps the price of a surprise from being invented on the day.
Change order
A written, signed note for any change in scope or price. No work outside the scope should start without one, and no payment should rise without one.
A bid with no unit prices for hidden damage leaves the price of the surprise to the crew who found it. That is not always a scam, but it is a risk you can price in advance by asking.
Compare bids on the same scope
Three bids with three different scopes cannot be ranked by price. Give each contractor the same job description, then put the answers in a table. The numbers in the last column are the ones you fill in from your own bids.
| Line | What to compare | Your notes |
|---|---|---|
| Quantity | Same measurement across bids? | Squares, feet or units in each |
| Materials | Same brand and product line? | Written name in each |
| Surprises | Unit price for hidden damage? | Yes or no, and the price |
| Permit | Who applies, who pays? | Contractor or you |
| Warranty | Workmanship, and for how long? | Years in writing |
| Payment | Deposit and schedule? | Dates and triggers |
To compare the price itself, divide each bid total by its quantity. For a roof, the bid total divided by the number of squares gives a price per square; for a fence, divide by the linear feet. The result is a way to spot a bid that is far from the others, not a price to aim at. A bid that is far lower than the rest has usually left something out. Ask what.
Exclusions, permits and payment terms
The lines people skip are the ones that cost them. Read the exclusions, which say what the price does not cover: paint after drywall repair, gutters, landscaping damage, electrical work. Read the permit line and see permits and inspections for why it matters. Read the payment schedule, too.
- Find the deposit. Ask what your state allows, and what the deposit pays for. A deposit that is most of the price is a risk to you.
- Look for payments tied to finished work, such as materials delivered or a stage completed, not to calendar dates.
- Hold back the final payment until the work is done, the cleanup is finished, the permit is signed off and you have a lien waiver.
- Pay by a method that leaves a record. Keep the receipts with the contract.
- If you plan to borrow for the job, read paying for home improvements before you sign a financing offer from the contractor.
Red flags and next steps
- A single-line price with no scope, quantity or materials.
- A bid that expires today unless you sign.
- Pressure to sign before you have the other bids.
- No license number, no insurance certificate, no permit plan. See how to hire a licensed contractor.
- A request that you sign over an insurance claim or pay the deductible in cash. See the roofing scam guide.
Take the bids home. A contractor who wants your job will answer your questions in writing, and a written answer is something you can point to later. Keep the bid, the contract and every change order in one folder.
Common questions
Is an estimate the same as a contract?
No. An estimate may change, and a contract is a signed agreement that sets the scope and price. Ask which document you hold, and do not treat an estimate as a fixed price.
Should I always pick the lowest bid?
Not without checking the scope. A much lower bid often leaves out materials, permits, cleanup or warranty. Compare scope first, then price.
What is a change order?
A written, signed change to the scope or price of a job. Without one, you may end up in a dispute over who agreed to what. Ask that the contract require a signed change order before any extra work starts.
Do states regulate home improvement contracts?
Many do, with rules on written contracts, required notices and deposits. The rules differ by state, so check with your attorney general's consumer office and see the state help hub.
Sources
- FTC Consumer Advice: How To Avoid a Home Improvement Scam
- FTC Consumer Advice: Home Repair Scams
- Minnesota Attorney General: Home Building and Remodeling handbook
Source links were checked on November 19, 2026 for title and address only; this guide states no prices, dollar limits or state contract rules. Contract and deposit rules are state law and change: confirm them with your attorney general's consumer office.
Next on the job
-
Project
Roof replacement
Tear-off, squares, ventilation and the questions to ask before you sign a bid.
-
Guide
Hire a licensed contractor
Check the license, the insurance and the permit plan before you sign. Licensing is state law.
-
Guide
Paying for home improvements
Cash, home equity, PACE, FHA 203(k) and Title I, and contractor financing: the risks and the questions to ask.