Skip to content
RoofElm

Scams

How to spot a roofing or storm chaser scam

The pitch after a hail or wind storm, the papers to refuse to sign, and who to call instead.

By RoofElm Editorial Team Updated 7 min read

Storm claims are run by
You and your insurer
Deductible waivers
Illegal in many states
Report to
State attorney general
Claim questions to
State insurance department
Illustration: a homeowner at the front door looking at a contractor's clipboard after a storm
A knock on the door after a storm is a reason to slow down, not to sign.

In short

After a storm, some roofers arrive unasked, offer a free inspection and push you to sign the same day. Not every door-knocker is a scam, and local roofers also canvass. Slow down anyway. The warning signs are an offer to waive or cover your deductible, a form that signs your insurance claim over to the contractor, a demand for a large deposit, and pressure to sign today. Insurance and contractor rules are state law, so check yours on the state help pages and with your state insurance department.

Why storms bring door-knockers

After hail or high wind, many roofs in a town need work at once. Local roofers get busy. Crews from out of town, sometimes called storm chasers, arrive to pick up the work. Some do honest jobs. Others take a deposit and leave, do poor work, or leave you with a claim you do not control. The problem is not that a contractor is from out of town. The problem is a pitch built to get your signature before you have checked anything.

You are not under pressure from the weather. A damaged roof can be covered with a tarp while you check licenses, get other bids and talk to your insurer. Your policy generally expects you to protect the property from further damage, so keep the receipt for a tarp or emergency repair and ask your insurer what it covers.

Warning signs on the doorstep

  • An unsolicited knock with a claim that your roof has storm damage and the offer of a "free inspection." An inspection can be honest. Ask who is paying for it and what you must sign to get it.
  • A promise to cover, waive or rebate your deductible. See the next section.
  • A rush. "The price is only good today," or "the insurance window is closing."
  • A large deposit, or a request for payment in cash, by gift card or by wire.
  • No local address, no state or city registration where one is required, and a license number you cannot find on the state board's site.
  • An out-of-state truck and a first name only. Ask for the full business name and the license or registration number, then verify them.
  • Promises about the claim. A contractor cannot promise what your insurer will approve.

Do not let anyone onto your roof until you have their name, business name and license or registration information in writing. The checks in how to hire a licensed contractor take an hour and are worth it.

The deductible

Your deductible is the amount you pay before your insurance pays the rest. An offer to waive, absorb or rebate it sounds like a favor. In many states it is illegal for a contractor to make such an offer, and it can amount to insurance fraud, because the insurer is billed for a bigger job than the one you are paying for. Rules differ by state. Ask your state insurance department or attorney general what yours say.

If a contractor's offer depends on the deductible vanishing, the invoice will probably be padded or the job will be done with cheaper materials than the claim pays for. Either way, you carry the risk.

Papers you should not sign in a hurry

Some storm contracts include a clause that assigns your insurance benefits to the contractor, sometimes called an assignment of benefits. The contractor then deals with the insurer directly, and you may lose a say in how the claim is handled. Rules about these assignments vary by state, and some states restrict them. Read the NAIC's consumer pages on signing away your benefits and ask your state insurance department how your state treats assignments.

  1. Read every page. Ask for a copy before you sign, and take the time to read it at the kitchen table.
  2. Look for a clause that assigns your claim, lets the contractor negotiate with your insurer, or gives the contractor a power of attorney.
  3. Look for a cancellation or termination fee, and check how and when you can back out. The FTC's Cooling-Off Rule gives a three-day right to cancel many sales made at your home, with exceptions, so read the FTC page. Some states add rules for storm-damage work.
  4. Never sign a completion certificate or a final payment form before the work is done and inspected.
  5. If you do not understand a line, do not sign. Ask your insurer or a lawyer.

Contracts, warranties and lien waivers explains the paperwork around a payment, and the estimate reading guide shows what a bid should name.

What to do instead

  1. Photograph the damage from the ground, with a date, before anyone climbs up. Do not climb up yourself in wet or windy weather.
  2. Call your insurer and file the claim in your own name. Ask what the policy covers and what your deductible is.
  3. Make temporary repairs if needed, such as a tarp, and keep every receipt.
  4. Get at least two written bids from licensed or registered local contractors, and compare them on the same scope. A roofer with an office, a history and references is easier to find a year later.
  5. Let the insurer's adjuster inspect the roof. You may be able to have your contractor present; ask your insurer.
  6. Sign only after you have read the contract, checked the license and insurance, and confirmed the permit plan. See permits and inspections.

Whether the repair is worth it or a full replacement is the right call is a separate question, covered in roof repair or replace. How your roof's age affects what the insurer pays is in roof age and homeowners insurance.

Who to call and what to report

Your insurance company

Start here for any claim. Ask for your claim number, your deductible and what documents the insurer wants.

State insurance department

Regulates insurers and, in many states, public adjusters and claim practices. The NAIC site links to each state's department.

State attorney general

Takes consumer complaints about contractors and unfair sales practices. Many states have a consumer protection hotline.

Better Business Bureau

Runs scam alerts and a scam tracker. Use it to report and to read warnings, not as proof a contractor is honest.

Report a scam even if you did not lose money. Your report helps the agencies see a pattern and warn the next neighbor. The FTC also takes reports at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. If you paid by card and the work was never done, call the card issuer promptly and ask about disputing the charge.

Common questions

Is it legal for a roofer to waive my deductible?

In many states, no. Rules vary, so ask your state insurance department or attorney general. In Texas, for example, the law requires you to pay your deductible and a contractor who offers to waive it is breaking the law.

Is every roofer who knocks on my door a scammer?

No. Local roofers also canvass after storms. What matters is whether you can verify the license, insurance and references, and whether the contract and payment terms are fair. Never sign the same day under pressure.

Should I sign a contract that assigns my insurance claim to the contractor?

Not without reading it carefully and asking your insurer and state insurance department how assignments work in your state. You can lose control of the claim.

Where do I report a roofing scam?

Report it to your state attorney general's consumer office, your state insurance department if an insurance claim was involved, the Better Business Bureau scam tracker, and the FTC.

Sources

Source links were checked on November 19, 2026 for title and address only; the Texas deductible rule is taken from the Texas Home Help page. Insurance claim and contractor rules are state law and change: confirm them with your state insurance department and attorney general.